Wave & particle models of light
There are six main properties of light that should be explained by a theory of light. The wave model and the particle model explain them with varying degrees of success.
- linear propagation
-
Light propagates in straight lines. It does not fall and hit the floor.
- Particle: light is composed of very small, fast-moving particles.
- Wave: no good explanation.
- diffraction
-
Light diffracts when it passes through a slit.
- Particle: particles collide with the sides of the slit and scatter.
- Wave: water analogy.
- reflection
-
Light reflects off many surfaces.
- Particle: pool table analogy.
- Wave: water analogy.
- refraction
-
Light refracts when it enters a different medium.
- Particle: the particles move at different speeds in different media.
- Wave: water analogy.
- partial reflection & refraction
-
Window panes reflect part of the incoming light and transmit the rest, depending on the viewing angle.
- Particle: no good explanation.
- Wave: water analogy.
- dispersion of white light
-
White light disperses into the colours of the rainbow when it passes through a prism.
- Particle: different colours of light are made of particles of slightly different mass (red is heavy, violet is less heavy).
- Wave: each colour is a wave with a different wavelength (red is long, violet is short).
The wave model seems to do a better job of explaining most of these properties, but in reality the answer is more complicated than that.